Shay wakes up, feeling groggy and terrible. Two uniformed police officers are in her apartment. Hazily, she looks around and notices the scalpel and bloody towel as well as a wallet and watch she does not recognize. She asks the police what is going on, and they respond by asking her to explain what happened last night. She has no idea. She has no memories of what happened after Cassandra and Jane came over.

The police take her to the station for questioning. Detective Williams is there, and Shay wonders what she thinks of her makeover and of the fact that she’s living in Amanda’s old apartment.

Two Months Ago

Two months prior, Amanda stands over James’s convulsing body with Cassandra, Stacey, and Valerie. She panics as the women begin to carve the word “rapist” into his forehead. He is clearly having a reaction to the medication she gave him. She is a trained nurse and yells out that she has to save his life. The other women disagree, noting that he showed no mercy to Daphne during the attack.

The plan had not been to kill him, and Amanda is horrified.