After telling Annie and Jeanie everything that has happened with Noah, Hazel’s friends try to convince her that Noah is in love with her, and she admits that she is in love with him. Hazel doesn’t know what to do, especially since she doesn’t know whether Noah will return to Dream Harbor. Annie and Jeanie are convinced that Noah is the one leaving the clues, and they think he has a grand finale planned for her birthday. As the three enter the bookstore, Alex tells Hazel that another book has been marked up. The book is a diary with Hazel’s birthday circled, and a note telling her to go to Mac’s bar at seven o’clock that night and bring friends.

Noah gets a text from Hazel as he is looking into getting forms for his beach rentals. He hopes starting to work on this idea will prove to Hazel that he is good enough for her and that he will be back in Dream Harbor after he is done helping his sister. However, he is confused because Hazel’s details about the new clue are sparse. He receives another phone call that he expects is from his nieces, yet he is surprised to see his entire family calling on the phone.