Annie is curious about how far the sleeve of flower tattoos extends up Will’s arm, and he gives her permission to remove his shirt. As her hands trail his skin, Will asks if she’s a virgin, which Annie confirms. They begin kissing, and when things become heated and Will reaches to unbutton her top, Annie stops it from going further. Will is respectful and cuddles with her instead. Annie believes she detects fear in his eyes.

Will wakes up with Annie and wonders if he can have a long-term relationship. For the first time, he understands what his brother means when he talks about his love for Hannah. Though he wants to stay, Will sneaks back out Annie’s bedroom window and heads to the local diner for breakfast. Noah is present, grabbing his morning coffee, and knows about Will’s night with Annie. Apparently, everyone in town has seen his truck, and the news has spread like wildfire. James enters the diner as well, with a petition begun by Harriet at a town business owners’ meeting earlier this morning. The petition demands that Annie and Will cease their relationship for Annie’s protection.