Mr. Lincoln’s former law partner, Mr. Herndon, holds several lectures about the late president; he makes several illegitimate claims about Mr. and Mrs. Lincoln’s marriage lacking love and affection. Although Mr. Herndon receives negative criticism for his lectures, the assertions emotionally wound Mrs. Lincoln. Robert Lincoln threatens to sue Mr. Herndon if he continues to write about his family’s private life. Mr. Lincoln’s pastor defends Mrs. Lincoln, citing his personal experience witnessing the loving bond between the couple.

Two years later, Mrs. Lincoln resorts to selling her dresses for additional income; she asks Elizabeth to meet her in New York City to assist with the endeavor. Mrs. Lincoln travels under “Mrs. Clarke” for added protection as she stays in a humble, affordable hotel. Elizabeth faces discrimination and hurtful prejudice from the owner of the hotel. The hotel’s manager refuses Elizabeth a suitable room near Mrs. Clarke/Mrs. Lincoln, and he denies her dinner. Elizabeth focuses on helping her close friend instead of allowing her anger and frustration to spoil their reunion.

Mrs. Lincoln informs Elizabeth about an early meeting she conducted with a jewelry buyer. Though she tried to remain anonymous, a partner at the company recognized Mrs. Lincoln’s name engraved on one of her rings.