“What’s true, what’s myth? It’s hard to know. […] But that’s okay, because the history of a kid is one part fact, two parts legend, and three parts snowball. And if you want to know what it was like back when Maniac Magee roamed these parts, well, just run your hand under your movie seat and be very, very careful not to let the facts get mixed up with the truth.”

With this contemplative quote from the chapter that serves as a prologue, Jerry Spinelli sets the playful yet profound tone that characterizes the narrative. By speaking directly to the reader, the author blurs the boundary between fiction and reality and invites contemplation on the elusive distinctions fact and fiction, truth and myth: a theme that is essential to the story. This moment also establishes the “tall tale” mood of the novel, priming readers to expect the entrance of a kid who defies convention in every way imaginable, and when he does appear, Jeffrey “Maniac” Magee does not disappoint.

“‘I’m from Bridgeport.’

‘Bridgeport? Over there? That Bridgeport?’

‘Yep.’

‘Well, why aren’t you there?’

‘It’s where I’m from, not where I am.’

‘Great. So where do you live?’

Jeffrey looked around. ‘I don’t know…maybe…here?’”

In his first conversation with Amanda, Maniac’s search for a home and family becomes clear in his refusal to tie his personal identity to his place of origin. Instead, he actively claims Two Mills as a home simply because that is where he currently is. His past is in Bridgeport—and he notably doesn’t even mention Hollidaysburg or his parents; thus, it is evident from the very beginning of the story that with his arrival in Two Mills, he is attempting to create a fresh start for himself and hoping that this town might offer him a good future.